Gear materials

No single material is best for gears. The right one depends on the load, the speed, what the gear runs against, the environment and how many you need. This page covers when laser-sintered nylon is a good choice, and how it compares with acetal, brass, aluminum and the common stainless steels.

Nylon 12, laser sintered (PA 2200)48 MPaAcetal, POM65 MPaNylon 66, molded or machined, dry82 MPaAluminum 6061-T6310 MPaFree-machining brass, C360385 MPaAluminum 7075-T6570 MPaStainless 303 / 304 / 316, annealed600 MPaNitronic 60, annealed720 MPaStainless 416, hardened900 MPaStainless 17-4 PH, H9001310 MPaStainless 440C, hardened1900 MPa301003001000MPa, log scale
Figure 1. Typical tensile strength, log scale. Values are typical data-sheet figures and vary with supplier, temper and heat treatment. Strength is only part of the story: wear, friction and stability matter as much in a gear.

What matters in a gear material

  • Strength and fatigue. These set the torque a tooth can carry for millions of cycles without breaking at the root.
  • Wear and friction. Teeth slide as well as roll. A material that runs smoothly against its partner, without lubrication if need be, lasts longer and runs cooler.
  • Dimensional stability. Swelling with moisture or heat changes the tooth thickness and the backlash.
  • Temperature and environment. Heat softens plastics; water, chemicals and food contact rule some materials out.
  • Process and quantity. Printing, machining, molding and hobbing each suit different volumes and accuracies.

When printed nylon gears are the right choice

Laser-sintered nylon 12 is a good gear material when the load is light to moderate and the design matters more than the last bit of strength:

  • Prototypes and low volumes. A custom gear costs the same as a stock one, with no tooling and no minimum quantity.
  • Shapes that can't be machined or molded cheaply. Gears with integral hubs, cams, spoke patterns or several gears in one part.
  • Dry, quiet running. Nylon runs without grease, damps noise and tolerates small misalignment better than metal.
  • Light weight and no corrosion. Nylon is about an eighth the density of steel and doesn't rust.
  • Replacement parts for appliances, instruments, models and older machines, where the original gear is no longer made.

Choose something else when:

  • The load is high. Check the stresses with the generator's load rating (load ratings). If a nylon gear needs a very wide face or a coarse module to survive, a metal gear will be smaller and more reliable.
  • Precision matters. Laser-sintered parts typically hold about ±0.3 mm (see how parts are made). For positioning drives and instruments, use a machined or hobbed gear.
  • It runs hot or fast for long periods. Plastics lose stiffness as they warm and shed heat poorly. As a rule of thumb, choose metal for continuous running above about 80 °C or at high pitch-line speed.
  • It sits in water or a hot, humid place where any swelling would upset the backlash. Nylon 12 absorbs much less water than nylon 6 or 66, but acetal absorbs less still.

Acetal (POM, Delrin)

Acetal is the classic molded and machined plastic gear material. It is stiffer than nylon, has a low, steady coefficient of friction and absorbs very little water, so its dimensions hardly change in humid conditions. That makes it the usual choice for small precision plastic gears in instruments, printers and appliances. Nylon is tougher under shock and handles higher temperatures. Acetal is attacked by strong acids and by some fluids such as glycol coolants. An acetal gear meshing with a nylon gear is a common, well-proven pairing, because two dissimilar plastics wear less than two of the same kind.

Brass

Free-machining brass (C360, about 3 % lead) is the most machinable common metal, which is why it is used for small cut gears in clocks, instruments and models. It runs quietly against steel, does not rust and needs only light lubrication. It is much stronger than any plastic but much softer than steel, so it is best as the gear rather than the pinion in a brass–steel pair. Its lead content rules it out for drinking-water and many food applications, and RoHS limits apply in electronics.

Aluminum

Aluminum gears are used where weight matters most: robots, drones, camera and instrument drives, and racing parts. They are about a third of the weight of steel and easy to machine.

  • 6061-T6, about 310 MPa, is the common general-purpose alloy. It has good corrosion resistance and anodizes well.
  • 7075-T6, about 570 MPa, is nearly twice as strong and is the choice for loaded aluminum gears. Its corrosion resistance is lower, and it can suffer stress-corrosion cracking in damp conditions.

Bare aluminum wears and galls readily, so aluminum gears are usually hard anodized (Type III). That gives a thin, very hard ceramic surface. The coating adds thickness, which should be allowed for in the tooth thickness, and it can crack under heavy contact loads. Run aluminum against steel, brass or plastic rather than against itself, and keep the loads moderate. For heavy duty, steel is smaller and longer lived.

Stainless steels

Stainless gears are chosen for corrosion resistance, cleanliness or strength in a small package. The grades differ a lot:

GradeTypeCharacterTypical gear use
303AusteniticSulfur added for free machining; slightly less corrosion resistant than 304; not hardenableLight-duty machined gears and shafts
304AusteniticGeneral-purpose corrosion resistance; harder to machine than 303; not hardenableFood and wash-down equipment
316AusteniticMolybdenum gives the best chloride resistance of the three; not hardenableMarine, chemical and medical equipment
416MartensiticFree-machining and heat-treatable for hardness; lower corrosion resistanceHardened gears and shafts in dry or mild environments
17-4 PHPrecipitation hardeningMachined soft, then aged to very high strength (about 40–47 HRC at H900) with little distortion; good corrosion resistanceHighly loaded compact gears; aerospace and instruments
440CMartensiticHigh carbon: the hardest stainless, with the best wear resistance; only moderate corrosion resistanceWear-critical small gears, bearings
Nitronic 60Austenitic (Mn–Si–N)Exceptional resistance to galling and wear; about twice the yield strength of 304/316; corrosion resistance between 304 and 316, with better chloride pitting resistance than 316Stainless-on-stainless gears, valve trim, fasteners

Galling is the main trap with stainless gears. Two ordinary austenitic stainless surfaces sliding together under load can cold-weld and tear. Avoid running 303, 304 or 316 against themselves without lubrication. Pair them with a different material instead, such as brass, bronze, acetal or nylon, or use a galling-resistant grade such as Nitronic 60.

Pairing materials

  • Plastic gear with a metal pinion. The metal carries heat away, and the pinion, which turns more often, gets the harder material. This is the most common mixed pairing.
  • Two plastics. Make them different (nylon with acetal) and keep the speed and load modest, since neither conducts heat well.
  • Brass with steel. A traditional quiet pairing for instruments and clocks.
  • Aluminum. Hard anodize it, and run it against steel, brass or plastic rather than another aluminum gear.
  • Stainless with stainless. Use a galling-resistant grade on at least one side, or lubricate.

Property values on this page are typical figures from supplier data sheets. Check your supplier's data for the grade and condition you buy.

Design a gear and check its load rating in nylon, acetal or steel. Open the generator.