How Protogears parts are made

We print gears by selective laser sintering (SLS) in nylon 12, on an industrial EOS machine in Chicago. The same file that generates your drawings and downloads goes straight to the machine.

Cut-away view of a laser sintering machine: laser, scanning mirrors and lens above a bed of nylon powder, with a gear forming in the powder
  1. X–Y scanning mirrors
  2. Beam-expanding lenses
  3. CO2 laser
  4. Focusing lens
  5. Heaters hold the powder just below melting
  6. Roller spreads a 0.1 mm layer
  7. Powder supply
  8. Supply piston rises
  9. Pyrometer reads the bed temperature
  10. Laser fuses the new layer
  11. Gear taking shape in the powder
  12. Build platform drops a layer
Figure 1. Inside a powder-bed laser sintering machine (schematic).

The process

  1. Your design becomes a build file. The STL is made by the same code that drew your gear in the generator, so the printed teeth are the teeth you saw.
  2. Parts are nested. Many orders share one build: parts are packed into the 200 × 250 × 330 mm build volume.
  3. The powder bed is heated to just below the melting point of the nylon.
  4. Layer by layer. A recoater spreads 0.1 mm of powder, and a CO2 laser traces the cross-section of every part, fusing the powder. The platform drops and the next layer is spread. Unfused powder supports the parts, so no support structures are needed and nothing scars the teeth.
1 Spread a layer2 Fuse the cross-section3 Lower by one layer
Figure 2. Each layer takes three steps. A gear 10 mm thick is built from about 100 layers.
  1. Cooling. The build cools slowly, for about as long as it took to print, so the parts do not warp.
  2. Unpacking and blasting. Parts are dug out of the powder cake and bead blasted clean.
  3. Inspection. We check gears by measurement over pins, the value printed on your data sheet.
  4. Packing. Each order ships with its data sheet.

What the laser does to the powder

Nylon 12 powder is a fine flour of grains about 0.05 mm across. The heaters keep the whole bed just below the melting point, so the laser only has to add a little energy: where it passes, the grains melt at their surfaces and flow together. The fused nylon is nearly solid, with a slightly grainy surface that gives SLS parts their matte finish.

Loose powder, grains about 0.05 mmAfter the laser: grains fused together
Figure 3. Grains before and after sintering. Unfused powder around a part is sieved and reused in later builds.

Accuracy to expect

Laser-sintered parts are less precise than machined or molded ones. Print services commonly quote tolerances of about ±0.3 % of a dimension, with a floor of ±0.3 mm. For a gear, the error that matters is the tooth thickness, because it sets the backlash. That is why the generator recommends at least 0.05 mm of backlash per gear for printed pairs and adds an allowance to bores. Every gear we ship is measured over pins, and the result is checked against the value on its data sheet. We will publish our own measured tooth-thickness and runout figures from our calibration prints.

Orientation

We print gears lying flat, with the axis vertical. The tooth profile then lies in the plane of each layer, so it is traced in one smooth pass of the laser, and the bending load on each tooth runs along the layers, where the material is strongest.

The material: nylon 12 (EOS PA 2200)

PropertyValue
Tensile strength, in the layer plane48 MPa
Tensile strength, across layers42 MPa
Tensile modulus1650 MPa
Elongation at break, in the layer plane18 %
Melting temperature176 °C
Density0.93 g/cm³

Values from the EOS PA 2200 material data sheet. Properties depend on build position and process settings.

Nylon 12 is tough, dimensionally stable, resistant to oils, greases and most solvents, and absorbs much less water than other nylons. Its fine-grained surface needs no finishing on gear teeth.

Design rules for printed gears

The generator checks every design against these rules before you order. Rules marked required block the order; the others appear as printing notes.

RuleLimitWhy
Wall thickness, anywhere0.8 mm, required; 1.5 mm recommendedThinner walls break during depowdering and blasting
Material under the teeth1.5 mm, requiredThe rim carries the tooth load
Hole diameter1.5 mm, requiredSmaller holes fill with fused powder
Tooth space near the root0.3 mm, required; 0.5 mm recommendedNarrow spaces fill with partly fused powder
Module0.5 to 5 mm (5 to 48 DP)Finer teeth are smaller than the process can resolve
Tip land0.3 mm recommendedNarrower tips print rounded
Solid sectionsUnder 10 mm in at least one directionThick solid sections shrink unevenly as they cool; spoke windows help
Large thin partsThickness at least 1/20 of the diameterThin discs and long thin racks can warp
Backlash0.05 to 0.1 mm per gear at module 1Allows for tolerance and moisture swelling
Bore allowance+0.1 to +0.2 mm for a sliding fitLaser-sintered holes come out slightly small

The general limits follow published SLS design guides; the gear-specific values will be refined from our calibration prints.

Accuracy

We are measuring the accuracy of our process with a calibration set of gears from module 0.5 to 2, and will publish the results here, together with the bore allowances that give a sliding fit. The finest teeth we accept for printing are module 0.5 (about 48 DP).